Young Americans smoke less than any previous generation. The bigger risk is how many have been told vaping is just as deadly.
The New York Post’s recent story on young people calling cigarettes “healthier” than vapes captured a real conversation happening on TikTok and Reddit. But the national data tell a different story: Gen Z is not taking up smoking. It is walking away from it.
In 2024, just 3.4% of Americans aged 18 to 24 smoked cigarettes. Among middle and high school students, the figure is 1.4%.
By common definition, a population with fewer than 5% smokers is considered “smoke-free.” When it comes to cigarettes, America’s young adults are already there.
The trend is still heading in the right direction. Adult smoking fell below 10% (9.9%) in 2024 for the first time in more than 60 years of federal tracking, and preliminary 2025 data put it at 9.1%. Despite the positive trend, for now, Millennials and Gen X are keeping cigarettes alive, not Gen Z.
Young people who use nicotine have largely switched to products that don’t burn tobacco. Among 18-to-24-year-olds, 14.8% vape while 3.4% smoke, more than four to one. From 2017 to 2023, the share of young adults who smoked only cigarettes fell by more than 80%. That is the outcome public health advocates spent fifty years chasing.
On the science, the doctors the Post spoke with were clear. “The vast majority of disease and death from smoking comes from combustion,” addiction specialist Dr. Sylvie Stacy told the paper. “It’s not the nicotine component itself.” Vapes and pouches burn nothing. Tufts public health professor Michael Siegel put it bluntly to Fortune: “Smoking is orders of magnitude higher-risk than vaping.”
Yet Americans have been told the opposite for a decade. In the National Cancer Institute’s long-running national survey, the share of adults who believe e-cigarettes are more harmful than cigarettes rose from about 3% in 2012 to over 30% in 2022, the last time the question was asked. Only 17% still knew vapes are less harmful. The damage shows in the latest round: in 2024, just one adult in eight said e-cigarettes can help people quit smoking, and most said they simply didn’t know.
That confusion was manufactured. In 2018, the FDA folded vapes into its youth anti-smoking campaign, and researchers link that move to the collapse in public understanding. Then came the 2019 lung-injury outbreak, which the CDC itself traced mainly to illicit THC cartridges and the additive vitamin E acetate, not nicotine vapes. The correction never received a fraction of the attention the scare did.
Once people believe the risks are equal, the cigarette starts to look like the more social choice. The UT Southwestern researchers warn that believing vapes are more harmful is linked to switching from vaping back to smoking. Even during the outbreak, the CDC told adults who had switched to vaping that they should not go back to smoking. That message got lost.
The stakes are incredibly high. Smoking still kills more than 480,000 Americans every year. Gen Z has done what decades of campaigns could not: it has largely stopped smoking. The agencies that spent years blurring the line between burning tobacco and not burning it now have one job: tell young people the truth about which product poses a greater threat to their lives.